ZentrumNeueLichtkultur — Review

Tokio Hotel
Arena Tour 2026

The Quasar
On a light show that outshines everything and swallows the differences

First Movement · The Assertion

The Circle

The beam of light is round.

Not always, not without exception; patterns are used this evening too. But the circle is the shape of least resistance. A single circle is harmless. Ten make a picture. Hundreds, laid over one another, intertwined, chasing one another and piled on top of each other, make something else: mass.

And light has a property that does not grow with its quantity: it makes things visible. Too much of it does the opposite.

Astronomy has an object for this: the quasar. It is among the brightest things the universe has to offer, and its centre does not shine by itself. The radiation arises in the heated matter that circles a supermassive black hole and releases enormous energy on its way in. The centre stays black. What happens around it is so glaring that the galaxy it sits in disappears in its glow: billions of stars, outshone by a single point that feeds on their matter.

Tokio Hotel’s light show is such a quasar. Nothing about it is dark. Every effect amplifies the impact of the next, until the sum of them is brighter than any single idea. No beam keeps its direction, no image its outline, no effect its distance from the next. What is outshone here is not colour but difference. And in the middle, where a thought ought to sit, it is black: beyond the technology that was planned in, nothing ripens. What shines are copies of what has been before.

Tokio Hotel’s arena tour is cleanly built, reliably run and equipped with everything the market currently has to offer. That is one of the few bows this text makes, and it makes it gladly. There is no shortage of material. Nor of technical skill. Only with design talent does the question arise whether it ever set out on the journey at all. And what is missing is the authority that would, for once, contradict one of these means.

The Configuration

It is easy to imagine how this show came about: not in the rehearsal room, but in the configurator. As when buying a new car, you choose the base model, then the colour, and then work your way down the list of extras from top to bottom. LED wall: yes. Floating platform: yes. Tilt function: extra charge, yes. Ribbon lift, catwalk, flamethrowers, confetti, pyrotechnics: yes, yes, yes. At the end, a sleek design with almost every extra stands in the hall, and it is a design that nobody designed. It was ordered.

Nothing has been created beyond the scope of what was available, and nothing suggests that anyone wanted anything else. That is what distinguishes a configurator from a design: the configurator knows only what is in the catalogue. A design begins where the catalogue ends.

The very first image of the evening is telling. Before a note has been played, the kabuki curtain hangs there, and it is emblazoned with advertising. The first surface the audience sees belongs not to art but to sales. Then the curtain drops, and it drops to music one knows less from concerts than from product launches: the same swelling build that has been used for decades to unveil machines, cars and textiles. The show begins like the presentation of a new model. And that is what it remains.

By the third song at the latest, the strategy is plain to see, and its name is abundance. You show everything you have, and you show it at once, and then you add a little more. That is not an escalation. It is a shop window. And a shop window has no dramaturgy, because it holds nothing back.

Second Movement · The Findings

The Course

This light show resembles show jumping. Every song is an obstacle, each in a different colour and shape, and each is cleared with a technically flawless jump. Approach, take off, land, applause, next obstacle. What you do not see is the course. A guiding idea that would make something different of the fifth number than of the twelfth cannot be discerned. No direction towards a thought. Only the ride from obstacle to obstacle. Where all the obstacles are about the same height, nobody waits eagerly for the next one any more. You can cheer and still be waiting for nothing.

The individual lighting images are not the problem. Many are uplifting, some are good. It is not the images that are illegible. What remains illegible is the handwriting that ought to connect them. Image A is replaced by image B, and nothing can be read from the change: no development, no intended contrast, no necessity.

Timecode makes this possible. It has its rightful place: a programme fixed weeks before the show reaches the hall demands a rigour of its own and grants the person at the desk the freedom to watch the running order. Only here that freedom is invested not in attention but in density. The more reliably time is managed, the more fits into it: relief turns into storage space. And what timecode promises, it delivers only by half. It promises perfection and delivers reliability: there were many good cues this evening, and not one perfect one.

You can see it in the breaks. Every zip and every zap in the music gets its own effect, divided between chases, phasers and bumps, until the break no longer pulses but simply flows along. Impact comes from restraint: few breaks, but ones that hit the mark. From dark into light, from light into dark. Whoever serves every accent has, in the end, set none.

The programming catches almost every fill, precise down to the sixteenth note. The drummer himself plays with remarkable consistency and assurance. And it is precisely where he departs from that assurance for a moment that the difference between human and machine becomes visible: the light still sets an accent that his sticks no longer set. The musician has changed the rhythm; the image holds to its appointment with the clock. That does not diminish his playing. It passes judgement on a dramaturgy that responds to liveliness with an answer decided long ago. For a moment the musician has become more alive. The light has not noticed.

In places, the relationship is reversed entirely. One might think that sound effects had been added to the composition so that the effects lighting programme had something to follow. That is a supposition, not proof. But it describes a reversal that has long since become the norm: the light no longer translates the music; the music supplies the light with its cue.

Psychology knows a related process from the word. If you say the word “light” thirty times in a row, in the end you hear nothing but a single sound; the word is still there, but its meaning has for a moment receded into the background. This is called semantic satiation, and one influential explanation assumes that the problem lies neither in the sound nor in the meaning, but in the connection between the two. This has not been measured for the lighting image, and this text makes no such claim. It is content to borrow the image. The beam remains a beam, the fan remains a fan, and the eye passes them on conscientiously, one after another. Only by the fortieth nobody asks any more what was meant by it. The audience is not dazzled. It is oversaturated with light, “light-sated”, so to speak. Dazzled, you see nothing; light-sated, you see everything and read nothing.

And here a thought experiment is worthwhile. Modern lighting desks can also generate looks by themselves; a random generator rolls the dice on colour, position and sequence. Imagine it had been left running for half an hour this evening. Nobody would have complained, and probably nobody would have noticed. That is not a joke at the programmer’s expense, but a verdict on what was programmed: a design that could not be told apart from its own random variant would have ceased to be a statement.

The Axis

Everything revolves around the central perspective. The stage construction is built around a central axis; above this axis the beams cross, below it the figures fall into line, and the camera finds in the middle what it is looking for. The middle is the point towards which everything here plunges: the gravitational centre of this evening.

Symmetry is no flaw, asymmetry no proof of daring. Mirror-symmetrical lighting rigs are widespread on concert stages, and there are solid reasons for that: they are easier to plan, to hang and to repeat from hall to hall. But prevalence is no proof of quality, and an organisational reason is not yet design. Mirroring along the central axis is above all the most convenient way of fitting a great deal of technology above a stage: of plastering a lighting design across the ceiling, left as right.

The problem with this rig is therefore not its symmetry but its unexamined adoption. Anyone who hangs the fixtures in strict mirror image imposes on every later picture an order that reproduces itself. A different figure would have had to be thought through in the technical design itself, in positions, angles, counterspaces; it can no longer be extracted from this rig after the fact. The balance is delivered ready-made; the composition merely has to call it up. That anyone asked whether this band and this evening need the central axis at all cannot be read from any image.

There is, however, only one place where this balance works out completely: in the middle, at the height of the FOH. That is where the control position stands. That is where the main cameras stand. That is where the VIP guests are parked. And that is where the images come from with which such a show is signed off, documented and promoted.

It was from there, too, that the lighting team photographed its own work. Not with the main cameras of the video direction, which belong to the show, but with their own stills cameras: devices for the picture afterwards, colour-graded, retouched and soon displayed on social media, where these shots can be seen. The fixtures are not aimed at this point. But the lighting images look as though they were composed for their effect as seen from this point: nowhere else are they so closed, so symmetrical, so presentable. The perfect symmetry for the perfect post. Whether this intention guided the composition cannot be proven from outside; the posts suggest it. So one may ask what such a lighting image is designed for: for the hall, or for the retouched photo in the feed?

The audience, by contrast, is spread across large parts of the hall, including far to the sides of the stage. From there, the same stage looks as if chopped off at its edges: an order whose logic no longer reveals itself from one’s own seat, composed for a view that very few in the hall have. Those who decide see the picture. Those who pay see the cropped edge.

The Surface

Where the axis does not tell a story, the surface does. The LED wall magnifies, typesets, archives, and it does so with a force that demands only one thing of the light: obedience. It is the visually dominant surface of the stage space, and everything else is subordinate to it. The surface thinks first. The light may confirm. Any contradiction in light would already be a disturbance of the leading lady.

The wall does not lack variety. Visual worlds come and go, spaces form and dissolve again, and at times one has the impression of attending a performance showcase for the media server. Sometimes the generative visual worlds make no particularly determined effort to conceal their closeness to Refik Anadol. Sometimes the largest image surface of the tour takes its cue from the visual language of a tabloid magazine. One could call this understatement. One could also call it by its name.

The visual worlds change as they do at the Eurovision Song Contest, except that here no performer changes: the same band, the same four, two decades of shared history. The LED wall possesses an almost unlimited repertoire of images. What it lacks is any memory of what it has just shown.

In any case, one has to distinguish between the light of a screen and the shaping of a space with light. The one can enrich the other. Here it outshines the other’s independence.

And yet, of all places, something succeeds on these surfaces. The live cameras find the musicians with striking assurance. The shot selection is precise, the key light carries faces and bodies, camera work and video direction mesh so naturally that their work becomes almost invisible. The images follow the action with barely perceptible delay. Above all, this direction resists a temptation: the live images are not visibly coated with the real-time effects that content designers like to reach for, with tools such as Notch, for example. That says nothing about which systems run in the background; what matters is the visible image. Every additional layer of effects costs time and pushes itself in front of the person it is meant to show. Here a face may remain a face.

The images have mastered something else that appears in no credits: leaving things out. The costumes, to which I shall return later, come across better through the vision mix than they do in the hall. The camera chooses the shot in which a fabric falls and leaves it before it creases; it finds the face, the hand, the silhouette and leaves the rest to the darkness beyond the edge of the frame. Only the videos shot on phones from the stands, raw and uncut, show what the framing left out. An image also consists of its edges. Here, someone knew where they were.

The strongest decision of this video direction is the decision against yet another effect. That is praise, and at the same time it is the weightiest argument against the rest. For it shows what one would otherwise hardly credit this production with: it can do without. Restraint, then, is not a question of ability. It is a question of will.

The Shelf

This show quotes considerably. The ride on the oversized champagne bottle is inspired by burlesque. The champagne glass pyramid, too, belongs to that world of demonstrative excess. Fireworks on the guitar neck have been a rock-show classic for decades. The ride over the heads of the audience has travelled a long way across other people’s stages. Ribbon lift, tilting platform, floating levels: proven means, good ingredients, no new inventions. A potpourri from the catalogue.

Quoting is not forbidden; nobody designs in a space without images. But a collection of quotations does not yet make a sentence of one’s own. What is missing is the acknowledgement: the gesture with which a staging places its quotation in the light and makes clear that it knows where it is taking from and what it intends to do with it. Without it, the quotation remains a grab at the shelf.

And this shelf is exceedingly well stocked. One could have turned a familiar technique against its usual meaning, brought a familiar ride to a halt, done without a shower of fire where everyone expects one. Originality comes not from new acquisitions but from a different context. Here, they acquired.

The Apparatus

The floating platform does not merely travel up and down; it leans and tilts. Where a vessel tilts, something is poured out; the platform pretends to pour out abundance. But between pouring out and spilling lies the whole difference. Pouring out is a gift: you share what you value. Spilling is what nobody held. At this show, a great deal of light is spilled.

At one point three musicians stand on the platform while it tilts forwards, secured, as they must be. Only the securing becomes an image, and not a flattering one: the staging puts its artists on a leash and puts them on display that way.

Then the costumes. They are irritating throughout, in the sense in which a chemical irritates the skin, or too harsh a light the eyes. There is an idea, there is effort, there is the courage to make a figure. A stage costume may well prevent movement if the performance finds a meaning in that. But in a pop show, whose bodies are supposed to respond to the music, such a restriction calls for a design answer. Here the body is laced in, pinned down, put into a pose; the figure has to carry its own splendour instead of moving within it, and so choreography cannot even begin. An answer to this is hard to make out. Perhaps the grand gesture is meant as compensation: arms outstretched, a Bengal flare in each hand. As a substitute for movement, that would be little. It is one more pose.

That the machinery could do more, it proves itself. In one song the singer steps onto the lift and descends to change, in the middle of the song, without announcement, gone. Later in the evening he lets himself fall backwards into the same lift shaft: a stunt, an image, a statement. The same mechanism, first as logistics, then as meaning. The difference is not a question of technology. It is a question of whether anyone was looking.

Even what is necessary remains undesigned. Stagehands in black scurry across the stage, the little elves of the scene change, whom nobody is meant to see and whom you see most clearly when they take down the masking drapes and carry them off. That is no reproach to those doing the carrying. It is a question for the design. This stage was developed specially for this tour, and yet the fabric does not disappear; it is cleared away. A curtain pulled up and out of the picture in a split second has been part of the repertoire of stage engineering for decades; for the audience, the fabric is then simply gone. Whether travel, loads and safety would have permitted this in this construction cannot be judged from outside. All that can be seen is that the transformation does not look designed along with everything else, but dealt with.

It is much the same with the cameras. Small, almost invisible camera technology has existed for a long time. Here, though, camera operators cross the picture with opulent rigs. What such systems have to achieve in optics, stabilisation and connection to the video direction cannot be checked from outside, and, as already said, there is nothing to fault in their images. But the visibility of apparatus and personnel is not a technical inevitability. It is a decision, even if in the picture it looks like none.

And at the rear edge of the stage the fall protection stands in the picture as a grille, as if someone had forgotten it during planning. A railing has to secure. It does not have to look indifferent. A dedicated, expressly reserved share of the budget for the design of such functional parts would not have produced additional pomp, but precision.

Third Movement · The Causes

The Market

While the tour runs, the marketing runs with it. Artists, production, manufacturers and brand partners form a cosmos in which visibility itself becomes currency. Who owes whom what is set out in contracts nobody outside knows. The situation is legible nonetheless: the number of fixtures would probably have turned out differently had their creator had to pay for them out of his own pocket. Those who do not pay for the material count differently.

The market feeds this quasar. Whatever can be sold as visibility receives energy; whatever would require a decision against the next effect falls into the black centre and does not come out again.

And one may ask whom this installation is actually for. The audience? After two decades of band history, there is no generation in this hall that would first have to be won over with every new effect. It is not the audience that demands this installation. The industry demands it of itself and charges it to the audience.

The economic logic explains the reticence in thinking. It does not excuse it. A work that may disappoint nobody cannot surprise anybody. Both are the same ability.

Built Distance

Every stage decides on a distance. This one decides on a large one: a deep pit, a high stage edge, a dividing strip that nobody crosses. That is no mere side effect of the technology. Pit width and stage height are dimensions that someone determines long before the first fixture is hung.

Elevation is the oldest instrument of representation. Pulpit, altar, throne, grandstand: whoever stands above the others is seen without being reachable. The pit fixes the distance, the height the direction of the gaze, and together they produce the asymmetry on which an arena lives. The many see the one, and the one sees a mass.

A staging may insist on distance; some art even needs it, and the theatre has founded entire schools on it. It only becomes questionable when a staging builds the distance and at the same time denies it. That is exactly what happens here. The cameras bring the faces, house-high, onto the side screens, the catwalk leads forward at the scheduled minute, a whole machinery works on the appearance of closeness, while the built arrangement reliably excludes it.

One can read it like this: here someone wants to be seen without being close. That would be a legitimate stance. Only it would have deserved a staging that admits it, instead of glossing over it with gestures that contradict it.

The Audience

The audience is no victim in all this. It brings memory, bodily knowledge, songs. Anyone who has known the chorus since their youth need not want to learn a new aesthetic grammar every time, and the pleasure in a familiar image is real.

But expectations do not fall from the sky. Anyone who has seen many arena productions recognises the sequence: the rising effect, the condensed cascade, the final excess. Comparison is the thief of joy, and it steals twice. It takes the surprise from the audience and from the staging the courage to risk one.

Once again, people will say that the band wanted it all this way. That may be true; nobody outside knows the agreements. Only that is no objection but the finding itself. In that case, the staging has succeeded as a service: what was ordered stands on the stage, it works, it impresses. But whoever fulfils a commission has delivered and has not yet designed anything. Precisely because it was ordered, it is not a further development but a reheating of the long-established.

A band orders what it already knows. The real art would be to show it something it did not yet know it wanted. The difference lies not between the old and the new, but between recognising and discovering. The one confirms the evening. The other would outlast it.

The Regulation

There is, after all, one contradiction this evening, only it comes from outside. On the question of intensity, someone else has a say: no designer, no production management, but a rule.

As early as 2015 the band’s vision collided with the physics of light. At the Heimathafen Neukölln in Berlin, beam fixtures ran up against safety rules; the band publicly called this an intervention in its creative freedom. Today powerful fixtures shine above the heads of the audience. The regulations, however, have remained, in the interest of the sensory organs that perceive. May insight, then, prevail over far-sightedness, so that perception does not remain mere effect.

It is a peculiar constellation. The last authority that still sets a limit on the intensity of this trade is not an artistic one but a protective one: limit values for what an eye may take in from a beam, and the minimum distances that follow from them. Upwards, there is hardly any weighing up in design terms any more. The audience’s retina is the only negotiating partner left, and it does not sit at the table in the production meeting.

The Pillory

Eleven years after the Heimathafen, the regulation has caused a stir once again, this time in Leipzig. According to the city, the public order office banned two effects on 13 November: the burning torch in the hand and the shower of sparks on the guitar. The reasoning is movingly sober. Anyone who uses pyrotechnic stage effects other than as provided for in the instructions for use must hold a certificate of competence, and according to the city neither of the two brothers has one. Art was not up for debate. The point was rather who holds the fire in their hand.

Whatever the background, the anger was predictable. If you take the spade out of a child’s toy box, screams are inevitable, and no timecode trigger is needed for that. The singer answered from the stage. He repeatedly gave the full name of the official in charge and had the hall boo him. There were no factual arguments whatsoever. Outrage is not an expert opinion. The powerful one in this story has a microphone and ten thousand listeners. The powerless one has a form. It was enough to prevent two effects. Against a hall chanting his name, it is not enough.

The production team, however, ought to be congratulated. It has come across a man who reads an application before he approves it, and who is not impressed by sold-out concerts. Thanks to people like him, after a concert one talks about taste and not about burns.

The band, too, has the right to voice criticism; nobody wants artists to fall silent before the authorities. But for what happened in Leipzig, the towns of earlier centuries kept a piece of furniture of its own. You were put in the pillory, your name was posted before the crowd, and the public carried out the punishment. Back then, the whole thing was at least preceded by a verdict. In Leipzig a simple announcement sufficed, and the internet spread this name far beyond the reach of the hall.

And the show? “Leipzig is getting a worse show,” the singer declared. The city states that alternative effects were proposed on site and rejected. A staging that loses quality without these two catalogue effects, and can think of nothing in response, has thereby revealed what it is made of.

One question remains that the outraged would do better not to ask themselves: what if this thoroughness did not stop at fire? What if someone measured not the brightness in lux but the radiance, weighted according to what the retina can tolerate, and compared it with the safety distances that the manufacturers themselves state in the manuals of their most powerful fixtures? This text leaves open what would result; it knows neither the measured values nor the risk assessments for the lighting system used, and it alleges no breach. It merely notes that the retina has no name that could be chanted from the stage.

The Bill

Quantity of material is not an aesthetic judgement. A show does not get worse because it brings out a lot. The same is not true of the environmental burden. There, quantity is the argument.

According to the information available to this review, the tour includes a transport operation of seventeen trailers and five tour buses. And a private jet. The published tour calendar lists Zurich for 10 November, Milan for the 11th, Leipzig for the 13th, Vienna for the 15th, Munich for the 16th. That documents the locations of the concerts, not the route of each individual vehicle, and it is certainly not an environmental assessment; nobody outside the production knows that. But it shows the scale: Zurich, Milan, Leipzig, that is two crossings of the Alps in three days. A tour can be planned with economic efficiency and at the same time create a considerable environmental burden. The one does not justify the other. Whoever puts the entire stage on the road and themselves in the air has to be asked what of it is needed.

Ecological conviction is not found in the press release. It is found in the itinerary. With the number of trucks, the order of the cities and the question of who drives and who flies, a production has given its answer long before anyone has asked it about its responsibility. A tour schedule is the industry’s most honest document on sustainability: it is not only written, it is also carried out. Whoever plans their journeys and transports in this way has already defined their stance on climate protection. A declaration of intent would then be nothing more than a footnote.

The counter-check is simple: nobody would spit at you if only half the equipment were brought out. Nobody. Halving it would not be a loss, but an invitation finally to choose.

Sufficiency is not the decorative commitment to one sparing effect in the third song. It begins with the decision as to which images, fixtures, transports and journeys can be done without. An overfull stage and an overfull fleet are two different problems with the same unanswered question: who selects?

Heavier than the freight weighs the signal. Every production of this kind sets the expectations of its recipients for the future. It raises the bar, and the next briefing begins where this one left off. Thus habit becomes convention, and convention a condition.

That it can be done differently, the band itself has shown. Sixteen years ago, on the tour for “Humanoid”, costume and stage design were more closely attuned to the performance than they are today. Sixteen years of technological history later, the stage can do everything, except that.

What remains open, then, is the question that ought to stand at the beginning of every lighting design and to which this evening reveals no answer: what was the designer’s maxim?

Fourth Movement · The Counterimage

The Four

What no bill accounts for stands in front of the whole construction. There is one element in this production that has had a form of its own for twenty years and has nevertheless remained in motion.

The singer and the guitarist have developed a dazzling, wilful presence that has remained recognisable over two decades without ever hardening into a single image. The bassist and the drummer stand beside them and appear almost demonstratively ordinary. The groundedness of the one pair earths the colourful escapades of the other. Nobody hung this tension, nobody programmed it, and nobody ticked it in the configurator.

The four musicians are the actual stage set.

From this follows an uncomfortable balance sheet. The most elaborate elements of this staging are at the same time its most interchangeable. The irreplaceable stands in front of them, without a load-in day and without a power connection, and is constantly outshone by the quasar at its back. The galaxy is still there. You just cannot see it.

Conclusion

The evening ends with “Durch den Monsun”. Where water once fell during this song, confetti falls today. Water is the image of the cycle: it rises, it falls, it returns. Confetti is the image of the single moment. The eternal water cycle has become a one-off autumn of confetti.

Leaves that never grew on any tree, that never put down roots and are swept off the hall floor after the applause. That is no environmental audit; a water effect has its price too. It is an image, and it sums up the evening. The one rain belongs to the world and returns to it. The other belongs to the show and ends with it.

What remains is the question of all questions: did this instrument still leave possibilities open, or was everything that could be drawn out of it drawn out?

Every organist knows the answer. An organ has stops, and you can pull them all. Then the whole instrument sounds at once, it gets no louder than that, and yet you have heard almost nothing of the instrument. For the art of the organ is registration: the decision as to which pipes stay silent.

This light organ was played all evening with every stop pulled out. Everything has been pulled out. Almost nothing has been drawn out. In the end the instrument is both at once: exhausted and untouched.

The show works for its audience, and the audience is right. Only working is the least one may expect from twenty years of stage experience and a fleet of this size.

I would like to see the two dazzling personalities of this band on stage even more often. Their individuality is an enrichment. Precisely for that reason I wish them designers who do not open the catalogue first, but who are able to contradict. People who see in a commission a possibility that has not yet been exhausted. That is no demand for more money, more technology, more spectacle. Quite the opposite.

A gobo is a shape that someone has cut into metal. It costs almost nothing. It only requires someone to know which shape they want to see. Against a quasar, no brighter fixture helps. Only an outline does.